# 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Page **1** of **2** • **1**, 2

## 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

See if you can solve this logic problem. You'll probably need a pen and paper for this one...

You have 12 balls. 11 balls are the same weight. 1 is either heavier or lighter than the rest (you don't know which). You have a set of scales, you can use 3 times to compare one set of balls with another (they tell you if set A is heavier or lighter than set B, or if set A and set B are the same weight).

So, using the scales only 3 times, work out which of the 12 balls is the odd one, and also, if it is heavier or lighter than the other 11.

Go! (no cheating with Google)...

You have 12 balls. 11 balls are the same weight. 1 is either heavier or lighter than the rest (you don't know which). You have a set of scales, you can use 3 times to compare one set of balls with another (they tell you if set A is heavier or lighter than set B, or if set A and set B are the same weight).

So, using the scales only 3 times, work out which of the 12 balls is the odd one, and also, if it is heavier or lighter than the other 11.

Go! (no cheating with Google)...

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Jamie wrote:See if you can solve this logic problem. You'll probably need a pen and paper for this one...

You have 12 balls. 11 balls are the same weight. 1 is either heavier or lighter than the rest (you don't know which). You have a set of scales, you can use 3 times to compare one set of balls with another (they tell you if set A is heavier or lighter than set B, or if set A and set B are the same weight).

So, using the scales only 3 times, work out which of the 12 balls is the odd one, and also, if it is heavier or lighter than the other 11.

Go! (no cheating with Google)...

Easy ! Pick up all the Balls and the Scales and throw them at Jamie as hard as you can, you wont know which is heavier/lighter but will feel less frustrated and not being able to work out the stupid puzzle

**Jon M**- Green Cowboy Meeple
- Posts : 222

Join date : 2011-10-05

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Jamie wrote:CAN YOU SOLVE IT?

NOPE

**SamVS**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1124

Join date : 2013-07-17

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

It's definitely solvable, without any trickery! You'd probably need a pen and paper for it though (you would have to super genius to do it all in your head). Everyone give up?...

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Jamie wrote:It's definitely solvable, without any trickery! You'd probably need a pen and paper for it though (you would have to super genius to do it all in your head). Everyone give up?...

No, will solve later - beware spoilers!

**Mattel**- Red Meeple
- Posts : 104

Join date : 2015-03-16

Location : Crookes

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Mattel wrote:Jamie wrote:It's definitely solvable, without any trickery! You'd probably need a pen and paper for it though (you would have to super genius to do it all in your head). Everyone give up?...

No, will solve later - beware spoilers!

OK, I

*think*I have a solution and lots of crossing out on a piece of paper.

**Mattel**- Red Meeple
- Posts : 104

Join date : 2015-03-16

Location : Crookes

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

4 groups of 3

Pick any 2 groups of 3... And weigh

3vs3 same (move to B) or pick heavy group (move to A)

A - pick 2 to weigh - if balanced 1 left out is heaviest... Otherwise scales tip to heaviest. (2 turns total)

B - use other 2 groups find heaviest group and move to C (2 turns so far)

C - pick 2 of that group to weigh - if balanced 1 left out is heaviest... Otherwise scales tip to heaviest. (3 turns total)

Ah just seen what I missed - you don't know it's heavier... Back to thinking...

Pick any 2 groups of 3... And weigh

3vs3 same (move to B) or pick heavy group (move to A)

A - pick 2 to weigh - if balanced 1 left out is heaviest... Otherwise scales tip to heaviest. (2 turns total)

B - use other 2 groups find heaviest group and move to C (2 turns so far)

C - pick 2 of that group to weigh - if balanced 1 left out is heaviest... Otherwise scales tip to heaviest. (3 turns total)

Ah just seen what I missed - you don't know it's heavier... Back to thinking...

**Aneurin**- Starting player token
- Posts : 2871

Join date : 2011-07-20

Age : 38

Location : Deepcar

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Yep, you need to also work out if the oddball is heavier or lighter; it's a bit fiendish!!

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Bloody hell Jamie! I've got better things to do than solving your problems...

I've figured it using up to 4 uses of the scale, just need to iron out the wrinkle...

I've figured it using up to 4 uses of the scale, just need to iron out the wrinkle...

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote:Bloody hell Jamie! I've got better things to do than solving your problems...

I've figured it using up to 4 uses of the scale, just need to iron out the wrinkle...

hehe I love this kind of puzzle Paul.

As a bit of clue; you should try and do weighings, such that you can get 3 results; 1. Scales tip one way. 2. Scales tip the other way. 3. Scales balance.

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

I think I've got it.

Should I post my solution now, or wait a little longer...

Should I post my solution now, or wait a little longer...

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Not that my solution is at all elegantly written. Will probably just confuse everyone more...

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote:Not that my solution is at all elegantly written. Will probably just confuse everyone more...

I had the same problem mate. Working it out is one thing. Explaining your solution, in a way that makes sense to other people, is another thing altogether!

Feel free to share solution though.

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Please do, Paul, not knowing is killing me.

**SamVS**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1124

Join date : 2013-07-17

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Here's what I came up with...

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote: -Take 2 balls from the lighter set and one ball from the heavier set and weigh them against one other ball from each set (2)

I can't process this.

**SamVS**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1124

Join date : 2013-07-17

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

I did warn you...

2 balls from the 4 that were on the lighter side of the scale and one of the four from the heavier side of the scale should be weighed against one ball from each side of the scale plus one unweighed ball.

Better?

2 balls from the 4 that were on the lighter side of the scale and one of the four from the heavier side of the scale should be weighed against one ball from each side of the scale plus one unweighed ball.

Better?

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Nice one Paul! Haven't read your full solution yet, but your solution is different from mine at this point...

-Take 2 balls from the lighter set and one ball from the heavier set and weigh them against one other ball from each set (2)

Are you weighing 3 balls against 2? (presumably you add one of the known to be good balls?)

At that point, I was weighing 2 balls from the lighter set, plus 1 ball from the heavier set; against the other 2 balls from the lighter set, plus one known to be good ball (from set C in the original weighing).

It's possible there are multiple solutions though!

-Take 2 balls from the lighter set and one ball from the heavier set and weigh them against one other ball from each set (2)

Are you weighing 3 balls against 2? (presumably you add one of the known to be good balls?)

At that point, I was weighing 2 balls from the lighter set, plus 1 ball from the heavier set; against the other 2 balls from the lighter set, plus one known to be good ball (from set C in the original weighing).

It's possible there are multiple solutions though!

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

No, not 3 balls against 2, when I said one from each set, I meant one from A, one from B and one from C. I.e. One from the heavy side, one from the light side and one that wasn't weighed.

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote:I did warn you...

2 balls from the 4 that were on the lighter side of the scale and one of the four from the heavier side of the scale should be weighed against one ball from each side of the scale plus one unweighed ball.

Better?

Does that leave you with two potential heavies and one potential light off of the scales? How do you determine one of the heavy balls off the scales isn't the rogue?

Last edited by Sam on Wed 27 May 2015, 23:45; edited 1 time in total

**SamVS**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1124

Join date : 2013-07-17

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

My solution...

12 balls problem and solution

Problem: 12 balls. 1 is an oddball, find it out, using 3 weighings, also determine if oddball is heavy or light (compared to other balls).

Each weighing needs to reveal as much information as possible. So, we should compare 2 sets of balls, A and B, such that there are 3 possible results (A heavy, B heavy, A and B balanced).

Notation / short-hand I used:

0 = control ball (known not to be the oddball).

1-12 = ball number 1 to 12.

[w?] = weighing number 1 to 3.

There are 24 possible results, 2 (heavy or light) for each of the 12 balls. I’ve checked and all 24 eventualities are accounted for in the logical result paths below.

1.2.3.4 v 5.6.7.8 [w1]

result of w1: balanced ...

9.10.11 v 0.0.0 [w2]

result: balanced (12 is the oddball) ...

12 v 0 [w3]

12 heavy = 12 is heavy

12 light = 12 is light

result: 9.10.11 heavy ...

9 v 10 [w3]

balanced = 11 is heavy

9 heavy = 9 is heavy

10 heavy = 10 is heavy

result: 9.10.11 light ...

9 v 10 [w3]

balanced = 11 is light

9 light = 9 is light

10 light = 10 is light

result of w1: 1.2.3.4 heavy ...

1.2.5 v 3.4.0 [w2]

result: balanced (6.7.8 is light) ...

6 v 7 [w3]

balanced = 8 is light

6 light = 6 is light

7 light = 7 is light

result: 1.2.5 heavy (1.2 is heavy) ...

1 v 0 [w3]

balanced = 2 is heavy

1 heavy = 1 is heavy

result: 3.4.0 heavy (3.4 is heavy OR 5 is light) ...

3.5 v 0.0 [w3]

balanced = 4 is heavy

3.5 heavy = 3 is heavy

3.5 light = 5 is light

result of w1: 1.2.3.4 light...

1.2.5 v 3.4.0 [w2]

result: balanced (6.7.8 is heavy) ...

6 v 7 [w3]

balanced = 8 is heavy

6 heavy = 6 is heavy

7 heavy = 7 is heavy

result: 1.2.5 light (1.2 is light) ...

1 v 0 [w3]

balanced = 2 is light

1 light = 1 is light

result: 3.4.0 light (3.4 is light OR 5 is heavy) ...

3.5 v 0.0 [w3]

balanced = 4 is light

3.5 light = 3 is light

3.5 heavy = 5 is heavy

12 balls problem and solution

Problem: 12 balls. 1 is an oddball, find it out, using 3 weighings, also determine if oddball is heavy or light (compared to other balls).

Each weighing needs to reveal as much information as possible. So, we should compare 2 sets of balls, A and B, such that there are 3 possible results (A heavy, B heavy, A and B balanced).

Notation / short-hand I used:

0 = control ball (known not to be the oddball).

1-12 = ball number 1 to 12.

[w?] = weighing number 1 to 3.

There are 24 possible results, 2 (heavy or light) for each of the 12 balls. I’ve checked and all 24 eventualities are accounted for in the logical result paths below.

1.2.3.4 v 5.6.7.8 [w1]

result of w1: balanced ...

9.10.11 v 0.0.0 [w2]

result: balanced (12 is the oddball) ...

12 v 0 [w3]

12 heavy = 12 is heavy

12 light = 12 is light

result: 9.10.11 heavy ...

9 v 10 [w3]

balanced = 11 is heavy

9 heavy = 9 is heavy

10 heavy = 10 is heavy

result: 9.10.11 light ...

9 v 10 [w3]

balanced = 11 is light

9 light = 9 is light

10 light = 10 is light

result of w1: 1.2.3.4 heavy ...

1.2.5 v 3.4.0 [w2]

result: balanced (6.7.8 is light) ...

6 v 7 [w3]

balanced = 8 is light

6 light = 6 is light

7 light = 7 is light

result: 1.2.5 heavy (1.2 is heavy) ...

1 v 0 [w3]

balanced = 2 is heavy

1 heavy = 1 is heavy

result: 3.4.0 heavy (3.4 is heavy OR 5 is light) ...

3.5 v 0.0 [w3]

balanced = 4 is heavy

3.5 heavy = 3 is heavy

3.5 light = 5 is light

result of w1: 1.2.3.4 light...

1.2.5 v 3.4.0 [w2]

result: balanced (6.7.8 is heavy) ...

6 v 7 [w3]

balanced = 8 is heavy

6 heavy = 6 is heavy

7 heavy = 7 is heavy

result: 1.2.5 light (1.2 is light) ...

1 v 0 [w3]

balanced = 2 is light

1 light = 1 is light

result: 3.4.0 light (3.4 is light OR 5 is heavy) ...

3.5 v 0.0 [w3]

balanced = 4 is light

3.5 light = 3 is light

3.5 heavy = 5 is heavy

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Sam wrote:Paul wrote:I did warn you...

2 balls from the 4 that were on the lighter side of the scale and one of the four from the heavier side of the scale should be weighed against one ball from each side of the scale plus one unweighed ball.

Better?

Does that leave you with two potential heavies and one potential light off of the scales? How do you determine one of the light balls off the scales isn't the rogue?

No, leaves you with just one potential heavy and one potential light off the scale.

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote:No, not 3 balls against 2, when I said one from each set, I meant one from A, one from B and one from C. I.e. One from the heavy side, one from the light side and one that wasn't weighed.

That's different to what I did.

I also had 3 vs 3 on my second weighing (assuming first weighing isn't balanced). So, first weighing, I have 3 sets of 4 balls, and weigh set A vs set B. If they don't balance, for weighing 2, on one side, I have 2 from set A and 1 from set B. On the other side I have the other 2 from set A and 1 from set C.

**Jamie**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1225

Join date : 2014-08-03

Location : Camelot (nr Intake)

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Im clearly as good at explaining logic problems as I am at teaching games.

**PaulC**- Starting player token
- Posts : 1688

Join date : 2013-06-17

Age : 45

Location : Sheffield

## Re: 12 balls, logical problem (bit like a game), can you solve it?

Paul wrote:

No, leaves you with just one potential heavy and one potential light off the scale.

You couldn't have two balls from the first weighing off the scales if you replaced a weighed ball with an unweighed ball in the second scale. You must have three. You've only put two heavies back on the scales of the original set of four. If the scales balance, which they might do as the spy is in deep cover on the table, you can't determine from one weighing which of the three balls is the rogue if you don't also already know if the rogue is a Sandor or a Tyrion.

You got weigh closer than I did (!).

**SamVS**- Count of Carcassonne
- Posts : 1124

Join date : 2013-07-17

Page **1** of **2** • **1**, 2

Page

**1**of**2****Permissions in this forum:**

**cannot**reply to topics in this forum

Today at 09:26 by PaulC

» Tuesday 24th July 2018

Yesterday at 17:02 by theatrekat

» Anyone fancy playing some chess?

Tue 17 Jul 2018, 13:58 by Jamie

» Games tonight! Friday the 22nd is June.

Tue 17 Jul 2018, 13:53 by Jamie

» Kickstarter is killing me...

Mon 16 Jul 2018, 13:13 by

Kes» Tuesday 17th July

Mon 16 Jul 2018, 10:35 by RikTheChief

» Star Wars - Imperial Assault Campaign Taster

Sun 15 Jul 2018, 22:37 by

Aneurin» Facebook Events

Wed 11 Jul 2018, 11:25 by RikTheChief

» Tuesday 10th July 2018

Tue 10 Jul 2018, 16:02 by adamkadabra